Sunday, March 19, 2017

Why aren’t Australia and Vietnam strategic partners?

HMAS Anzac approaches Ho Chi Minh City on the Saigon River, 2016. (Defence Imagery)
Why aren’t Australia and Vietnam
strategic partners?
Carlyle Thayer
17th March, 2017
09:41 AEDT
The election of Donald Trump as US president has increased strategic uncertainty about
the leadership role of the US as the 'indispensable power' in the Indo-Pacific. One obvious
conclusion is that Australia will have to redouble its defence and security engagement in
the region. There are signs that this is happening with Australia’s recent engagements with
Japan, Indonesia, Singapore and the Philippines.
But what about Vietnam? Why hasn’t it featured in Australia’s new outreach?
Why aren’t Australia and Vietnam strategic partners? Page 1 of 4 3/18/2017
Australia has longstanding defence and security ties with Vietnam that stretch back nearly
two decades. In 1998, Vietnam hosted its first strategic dialogue with Australia. The
following year Australia opened a Defence Attaché's Office in Hanoi and in 2000 Vietnam
A decade later Vietnam pressed Australia to raise bilateral relations to the level of 'strategic
partnership'. This was rejected by then Prime Minister Kevin Rudd. Vietnam was
disappointed and in 2009 begrudgingly accepted Australia’s proposal that bilateral
relations be raised to a comprehensive partnership.
The Comprehensive Partnership agreement laid the foundation for the development of
defence and security cooperation. Australia and Vietnam declared that the 'security and
prosperity of both countries is linked to a secure future for the Asia-Pacific region' and
pledged to 'work together in regional forums to develop credible security architecture'. To
this end, Australia and Vietnam pledged to exchange defence personnel, conduct joint
training, host ship visits, and conduct regular dialogues on regional security issues between
foreign affairs and defence officials.
In 2010 the defence ministers of Australia and Vietnam signed a Memorandum of
Understanding on Defence Cooperation. The MoU extended defence engagement from
reciprocal education exchanges to a limited number of practical training activities between
their navies and special forces. A key component of defence cooperation has been
Australia’s provision of English language instruction and specialist training for Vietnamese
personnel about to deploy to the South Sudan on UN peacekeeping operations.
As a result of the MoU, Australia and Vietnam inaugurated Defence Cooperation Talks, a
Strategic Dialogue involving deputy secretaries from Foreign Affairs and Defence (2012),
and a Defence Ministers’ Meeting (2013), all on an annual basis.
In 2014 Vietnam once again pressed Australia unsuccessfully to raise bilateral relations to a
strategic partnership level. Nonetheless, the following year, during the visit of Vietnam’s
Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung, Australia and Vietnam adopted a declaration on
Enhancing the Comprehensive Partnership to signal growing bilateral ties. This declaration
laid out a road map for cooperation at international and regional levels, including
promoting the East Asia Summit as a leader-led forum, and the centrality of the Association
of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN).
Australia and Vietnam reached a convergence of views on territorial disputes in the South
China Sea. They stressed:
Why aren’t Australia and Vietnam strategic partners? Page 2 of 4 3/18/2017
The declaration also included a section on defence ties. It stated that both parties 'will
strengthen the exchange of views on regional and security issues of mutual concern by
maintaining a programme of regular consultations and visits at civilian official and military
levels' including the annual bilateral talks mentioned above, as well as an annual Defence
1.5 Track Dialogue. Australia and Vietnam also pledged to work together to achieve shared
security goals in the ASEAN Regional Forum, ASEAN Defence Ministers’ Meeting Plus, and
the Expanded ASEAN Maritime Forum.
Bilateral defence cooperation has continued through personnel exchanges, officer training
and naval ship visits. Other areas of cooperation include aviation and maritime security,
peacekeeping, counter-terrorism, special forces, and war legacy issues.
Vietnam promotes a foreign policy of 'independence and self-reliance', and a defence
policy that prohibits alliances and foreign bases on Vietnam's soil. In 2007, in an important
development, Vietnam was the Asia Bloc’s unanimous nominee for a seat on the UN
Security Council as a non-permanent member. Vietnam received the overwhelming
endorsement of the UN General Assembly and served from 2008-09. Vietnam is currently
seeking re-election in 2020 and is poised to deploy a field hospital to South Sudan. Vietnam
has also engaged in a robust program of defence self-help involving the modernisation of
its naval and air forces. In the period 2011-15, Vietnam was the eighth largest importer of
arms globally.
Vietnam has reached out to negotiate eleven strategic and fifteen comprehensive
partnership agreements involving all five permanent members of the UN Security Council,
and other major powers such as India and Japan. Vietnam’s strategic partners are given
more extensive access to its top leadership than comprehensive partners.
It is time for Australia to pick up some of the slack regionally as the Trump Administration
pursues an America First policy. The time is right to advance bilateral relations to a
strategic partnership level. Australia and Vietnam share convergent security views and
Vietnam has the capacity to work with Australia to address maritime security issues.
...the importance of maintaining peace and stability in the region, and ensuring
security, safety and freedom of navigation and aviation, in accordance with
international law, including the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the
Sea, without resorting to the threat or use of force. Both countries call on all parties
to exercise restraint and refrain from actions that could increase tensions in the
region. Both countries agree on the urgent need to conclude a code of conduct for
the South China Sea.”

Why aren’t Australia and Vietnam strategic partners? Page 3 of 4 3/18/2017
Why aren’t Australia and Vietnam strategic partners? Page 4 of 4 3/18/2017

No comments: